Posts
Why Most Leadership Training Gets Emotional Intelligence Completely Wrong
The bloke sitting across from me in the boardroom was red-faced, veins popping, absolutely losing his mind over a quarterly report that showed a 2% variance from target. Classic case of what I call "executive tantrum syndrome" – and it's more common than you'd think in Australian business.
Other Blogs of Interest:
Here's the thing that drives me mental about modern leadership development: everyone's banging on about emotional intelligence like it's some mystical superpower you either have or don't. Rubbish. After 18 years of watching executives implode spectacularly (and helping pick up the pieces), I can tell you that emotional intelligence training isn't rocket science – it's just that most trainers are teaching it backwards.
Most leadership programs start with theory. Big mistake. They sit you in a room, show you PowerPoint slides about the four domains of EQ, and expect you to suddenly become Daniel Goleman overnight. That's like trying to teach someone to drive by explaining combustion engines.
Real emotional intelligence starts with one uncomfortable truth: you're probably not as self-aware as you think you are.
Take Sarah, a regional manager from Perth I worked with last year. Brilliant strategist, hit every KPI, loved by her team. But put her in a room with the Sydney head office crew and she'd transform into this defensive, snappy version of herself. Took three months of brutal feedback sessions before she realised she was intimidated by their accents. Not joking. Something about the way they spoke made her feel like she wasn't good enough.
The Four Pillars That Actually Matter
Forget the textbook definitions. Here's what emotional intelligence looks like in the real world:
Self-Recognition Under Pressure This isn't about knowing you're stressed. Everyone knows when they're stressed. It's about catching that micro-moment before you respond poorly. Like when your biggest client calls at 4:57 PM on Friday with a "small request" that'll blow up your weekend. Most leaders react. Emotionally intelligent ones pause for literally two seconds and choose their response.
Reading the Room (Not Just Individual Emotions) Sure, you can spot when Dave from accounting is having a rough day. But can you sense when the entire team dynamic has shifted? When there's unspoken tension about redundancies? When people are excited about a project but afraid to show it because leadership seems lukewarm? This is where 73% of senior managers fail spectacularly – they read individuals fine but miss group emotional currents entirely.
Emotional Contagion Management Your mood spreads faster than gossip in a small office. I learned this the hard way during the 2019 restructure at my previous company. I was stressed about my own job security, trying to act confident, but apparently I was giving off "impending doom" vibes. Within a week, my entire team was updating their LinkedIn profiles. Your emotional state as a leader is never just yours.
Strategic Vulnerability This one's counterintuitive and most Aussie leaders hate it. Being vulnerable isn't about oversharing or appearing weak. It's about strategically showing your human side to build genuine connections. Admitting when you're out of your depth. Asking for help. Acknowledging mistakes quickly and without drama.
The thing is, Melbourne business culture especially rewards the "she'll be right" attitude, which is brilliant for resilience but terrible for emotional development. We're taught to push through, not feel through.
Where Traditional Training Falls Apart
Most corporate emotional intelligence programs are designed by people who've never managed a P&L or dealt with an angry customer at 6 AM. They focus on:
- Identifying emotions (usually through ridiculous facial expression charts)
- Theoretical frameworks that sound impressive in presentations
- Role-playing scenarios that bear no resemblance to actual workplace situations
- Generic communication techniques that ignore industry context
What they should focus on:
Real-time emotional decision making. Like when your star performer threatens to quit unless you fire their colleague. Or when you need to announce budget cuts the same week you've been pushing team morale initiatives.
Industry-Specific Triggers A mining foreman's emotional challenges are completely different from a tech startup founder's. Yet most training treats all leaders like they work in the same beige corporate environment. In construction, emotional intelligence might mean knowing when site safety is being compromised by ego conflicts. In retail, it's reading customer frustration before it escalates and spreads to other shoppers.
The Uncomfortable Truths Nobody Talks About
Some people genuinely struggle with emotional intelligence more than others. Not because they're bad people, but because of neurodiversity, cultural backgrounds, or simply different wiring. Instead of pretending everyone can achieve the same level of emotional sophistication, smart organisations work with people's natural strengths.
I've got a client in Adelaide who's brilliant with data, terrible with people emotions, but exceptional at creating systems that prevent emotional conflicts. Rather than forcing him into emotional coaching, we built processes that play to his analytical strengths while protecting his team from his emotional blind spots.
The other thing – and this really winds up the feelgood crowd – some workplace situations require less emotional intelligence, not more. Crisis management, urgent decision-making, certain types of negotiations. Sometimes you need someone who can compartmentalise emotions and just get things done.
What Actually Works: The Perth Method
I accidentally discovered this approach while working with a resources company in Perth. Their leadership team was technically competent but emotionally tone-deaf. Traditional training had failed twice.
Instead of starting with self-awareness exercises, we started with impact awareness. We videoed them in actual work scenarios (with permission), then showed them how their emotional responses affected business outcomes. Not how they felt, but what happened as a result of how they felt.
Game changer.
When you see footage of yourself dismissing a concern that led to a $50K mistake, or watch your team's body language shift when you walk into a room stressed, emotional intelligence stops being touchy-feely nonsense and becomes business critical.
The Money Factor
Here's something most training providers won't tell you: emotional intelligence training often fails because organisations don't address the financial stress that's driving emotional dysfunction. You can't teach someone to be emotionally regulated when they're genuinely worried about keeping their job or hitting impossible targets.
Qantas figured this out during their recent challenges. Instead of just rolling out emotional intelligence workshops, they addressed job security concerns first. Emotional regulation is much easier when basic needs feel secure.
Quick Wins That Actually Stick
If you're leading a team and want to improve emotional intelligence without the corporate training circus:
Start with your own emotional recovery time. Track how long it takes you to bounce back from setbacks. Most leaders don't even know their own patterns.
Institute the "24-hour rule" for emotional decisions. Any choice made while angry, frustrated, or excited gets revisited the next day. Not delayed – revisited.
Create "emotional weather reports" for team meetings. Quick check-ins about overall team mood before diving into business. Sounds silly, works brilliantly.
Teach emotional cost-benefit analysis. Before responding emotionally, ask: "What's this response going to cost me/us?" Most people can do basic maths even when they're wound up.
The reality is that emotional intelligence isn't a nice-to-have leadership quality anymore. In our hyper-connected, always-on business environment, emotional missteps spread faster and hit harder than ever. But it's also not some mystical skill that requires years of meditation and self-reflection.
It's a practical business capability that can be developed systematically. Just not the way most people are teaching it.
And honestly? The leaders who master this stuff don't just perform better – they sleep better too. Which in today's business climate is worth its weight in gold.
The bottom line: stop treating emotional intelligence like personal development and start treating it like any other essential business skill. Because that's exactly what it is.